I got a 10 gallon tank, added organic miracle grow with gravel on top, a few plants from petco, and four green tetra. The fish all died, the plants look almost dead, and the water always looks stirred up. I changed the about a third of the water every other day. What went wrong?

Views: 391

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

well according to u Everything went wrong..lol.   but on a serious note, did u cycle ur tank and filter b4 u added ur fish? What types of bulbs do u have? are they rated to grow plants? and for ur stirred up look, u probably used to big of size of gravel or ur cap was just too small. u should cap dirt w/  1 1/2" - 2" of sand or small gravel or w/e u chose. it would be best to add like sand to ur cap to fill in small gaps if u used gravel that was 2 big in size. or just add more cap if ur cap was 2 small

Everything did go wrong. Thank you, Peter. I have done a lot more research now. Too bad for the first round of fish and plants. I think maybe dirt isn't all it was cracked up to be. If I stick with it, I will as  sand to my cap. I didn't really cycle the tank because I used a water cycling kit from petco. I also just have the T8 fixtures that came with my tank. I am leaning toward just gravel. Obviously, I need to do more research before I try again. Thanks again. 

research is always good.  Remember dont always trust a chemical to do everything because it cant.  When keeping a dirted a tank, you must have patience AND MORE PLANTS than you ever thought you'd need

Did u test your water b4 adding fish? Also, dirt will release a lot of nutrients unlike in  normal tank, so even the chemical may not be enough.

Did you soak the soil first? When you don't a bunch of gases get stuck at the bottom that release once you fill it up that might be toxic for fish. You should mix some dirt or sand in and some clay to get a nice substrate, Also, petco sells their plants and fish in pretty bad condition so their pretty fragile so that might be why the fish died.. Typically, some plants melt away their leaves that are accustomed to a different setting and start growing new greens, so if you see that its a good sign it'll come back. The good thing is that Petco as a 30 day exchange policy on plants so you can get some new ones. Also, what kind of lighting are you running? Pink lights 6 hours a day is best. Hope this helps.

Depends what you local petco is like . I happen to be in very good standing with petco in my areas every fish i got from them survived . The manager personally ran this area of petco and made sure that every plant and fish was in good condition due to the fact that he was a planted tank keeper and want customers to have just as nice of a choice as he had.

Did you do this all at one time. Or did you cycle the tank a little first? Sounds like you had no bacteria established yet and the fish didnt survive the first night . Also some fish need a certain temperature ,including the plants. Now what im really wondering is did you buy topfin plants in the packages or did you buy potted. With planted tanks you can expect some plants to die off a bit before they become conditioned to the climate you have them in .So you should expect some melting . The water looks stirred up because you have dirt in it  takes a little while to clear up. If you want to clear it up faster i would say water change at 50% . that should help.

pretty mcuh

I fail. I am all settled in a new home and they are going to allow me to set up a tank. I think skip the dirt and just stick with gravel this time n wait to put my fish in for some weeks.

Petco probably uses pesticides on their plants... did you wash the plants off before putting them in the tank?



Top Content 

Blog Posts

Oscar cichlid tank mates?

Posted by Reece on March 23, 2017 at 11:45am 0 Comments

The Big Change

Posted by AquaristPaddy on March 19, 2017 at 4:09pm 1 Comment

Robert Steinbeck dirt mixture

Posted by Raecine Chaney on January 7, 2017 at 9:32am 0 Comments


soft water

Started by Ted Downing in General Discussion (off topic). Last reply by Ted Downing Feb 11. 3 Replies

Capping the Dirt!!

Started by Dylan Khantharasy in Dirt Converts Section Dec 6, 2016. 0 Replies


  • Add Photos
  • View All


  • Add Videos
  • View All


Birthdays Today

© 2017   Created by Dustin Wunderlich.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service